Shyam and Trupti broke up. So unbelievable. We jammed at Barista to console Shyam. He was really in a bad shape. He was in relationship with Trupti for more than three years, and she decided to dump him just because she had met a guy with financially better prospects. I instantly passed my judgment, “No surprise. Girls from that place are all for money. You should have thought about it initially itself”.
Vivek did not like my comments. One of his best friend is from the same place as Trupti, and he found my comments very offensive. “How can you generalize people in this way, this is completely unfair”. I found myself in a funny situation. This is the same Vivek who has himself made generalized statements at innumerous times - “You know Italians are big Flirts”. “You know Brazilian babes are too hot”. “You know Americans are so open minded”.
I found myself in a funny situation. Come on Vivek - “A Bhogi trying to be Yogi” … but, Vivek is never in a mode to listen, once he forms an opinion. And in his opinion (at this particular moment) it was wrong to generalize people’s behavior (though at other times he does so himself). I said sorry to him and we changed the topic.
We came back home and life kept moving. In a couple of weeks Shyam started dating Anjali. Apparently Anjali had a crush on him from the college days and she had always admired him. But she could never come in to Shyam’s life because of Trupti. In a month, Vivek left to Mexico for an onsite assignment. I changed my job and moved to this new company. But, one question kept teasing my mind, “Is it really wrong to generalize people’s behavior based on a region or culture”? I am not very sure if this is correct, but personally I have come to a conclusion that it is very obvious. Such kind of generalization is not only natural, but it is also rational.
People in a given region, can not be an identical copy of each other. But, there are certain characterisitcs which are likely to be common amongst them. This characteristics evolve over a period of time and depend on general factors in that region - e.g. Climate, Food Habits, Prosperity, History & Culture. Since these factors are constant in a given region, the people in that region will have certain common characteristics. Again, not every one in that region will have exactly same characteristics, but there is likely to be a similarity.
Consider a few examples
******************************
- Consider a state like Punjab. Punjab has a agriculture based economy and it is known to be very prosperous because of the fertile lands. People in this state are very healthy and jovial. This is a very general opinion - which you will find mostly true. You might find people in Punjab who are not healthy or who are not Jovial. But, because of the stress free life style and an above average economy, people generally are healthy and happy.
- Now consider a state like Bihar - in this state economy is weak and corruption is very high. The common man in this region has to struggle for every small thing - So, people in this region are generally very hard working. They leave their state, come to cities like Delhi and Mumbai, and serve as cheap labour. It is very unlikely that a person from Punjab will move to a big city and work as a cheap labour - the economic conditions in Punjab defy that logic.
- Take the case of Mumbai - Mumbai provides a competetive and cosmopolitan environment - people who grow up in this city are generally ambitous, competitive and they have a broader mindset. It does not mean that no one in mumbai is lazy and unambitious. It does not mean that no one in mumbai is narrow minded and conservative. But, we can still speak of a general characteristics behavior.
***************************
I just came across this interesting article from Paul Graham where he has generalized the character of different cities. It is indeed an interesting article, and his analysis makes a great sense to me. In the modern times, where migrated population in cities is very high, it is even more natural that “similar birds will flock together”.
*********************
PS: Vivek keeps on sending us e-mail from Mexico about his adventures with South American Beauties. Having completely forgotten the fact that he is against generalizing people’s behavior, he writes to us about why babes out there are so hot. He is a real narrow-minded ass hole.